NSW Scraps Underquoting Reforms as Victoria’s Ban Shows Early Results

property underquoting ban: Property underquoting ban: the New South Wales government has shelved reforms just hours before they were due to take effect, while early data from Victoria suggests its own rules have done little harm to the market. Buyers and agents remain divided over whether publishing reserve prices improves transparency or pushes sales lower.

Property underquoting ban, Digimart Global (Australia): The New South Wales government has mothballed its underquoting reforms just hours before they were due to take effect, after Premier Chris Minns said real estate agents in his electorate warned the rules would make it harder for sellers. The same argument was raised against similar reforms in Victoria, which came into effect last month, but early data suggests they have done little harm so far.

Underquoting occurs when a home is given a price guide well below the seller’s real expectations, attracting bids and often inflating the final sale price. The practice is most common at auction, which accounts for about two in five sales in Sydney and Melbourne, and buyers say it can leave them frustrated after time and money spent on checks and due diligence.

What Victoria’s reforms require

Under the Victorian rules, sellers must publish the reserve, the lowest price they are genuinely willing to accept, at least one week before an auction. Vendors and agents must also inform prospective buyers of nearby comparable sales and publish property sale prices.

The Real Estate Institute of Victoria has called for the rules to be reviewed and potentially scrapped, arguing they could cause more auctions to fail and make sales riskier, although it is not yet clear those concerns have come to pass. The reforms do not apply to properties sold without an auction and without a fixed sale date.

Early data and what it shows

Melbourne’s auction clearance rate has fallen since the reforms took effect, but Sydney’s has fallen further, suggesting broader factors such as official interest rates rising to their highest level in 18 years after five rate hikes this year are also at play. Cotality data indicates auctions have become less attractive for sellers, with new listings increasingly opting for private sales, though research head Gerard Burg says it is not entirely clear how much of the change is due to the reforms rather than interest rate movements.

Property data app Homer analysed 2,164 sales in the past month and found that homes where the reserve matched the price guide had a 59% sale rate, compared with 50.4% for those that revealed a higher reserve. Homer chief executive Henry Pedersen said the reforms had not ended underquoting but had “shifted and exposed it”, with buyers now seeing the gap a week before auction rather than on the day.

The NSW decision

The scuppered NSW package proposed raising fines for underquoting and requiring a price guide on all advertisements. Minns cited concerns with one element, a proposed ban on agents cutting the advertised price below either their private estimate or a previous rejected offer, which he argued could leave sellers who overvalued their property unable to meet the market.

Sydney buyers’ agent Kimberley Ackerman said that element was poorly designed but the remainder of the reform could have been salvaged, arguing sellers should advertise the price they would accept on the day, even if it is high.

Lachlan Prescott

Lachlan Prescott covers Australian breaking news, national affairs, government policies, and major developments across the country. His editorial focus is on delivering clear, factual, and balanced news coverage for Australian readers.
Copy Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports

Explore Digimart Global