Underquoting auctions Victoria, Digimart Global (Australia): The New South Wales government on Monday shelved its underquoting reforms just hours before they were due to take effect. Premier Chris Minns said he made the decision after real estate agents in his electorate told him the rules would make it harder for sellers, according to the Guardian Australia report.
Underquoting happens when a home is given a price guide well below the seller’s real expectation, which can attract bids and inflate the final sale price. The practice is most common in auctions, which account for about two in five sales in Sydney and Melbourne.
What Victoria’s reforms require
Victoria’s rules, which took effect last month, require sellers to publish their reserve, the lowest price they are genuinely willing to accept, at least one week before the auction date. Vendors and agents must also tell prospective buyers about nearby comparable sales and publish their property sale prices.
The Real Estate Institute of Victoria has called for the rules to be reviewed and potentially scrapped, arguing they could cause more auctions to fail, inflate reserve prices and make sales riskier. Early evidence on those concerns is not yet conclusive.
Early data is mixed
Melbourne’s auction clearance rate has fallen since the reforms began, but Sydney’s has fallen further, suggesting broader factors such as official interest rates at their highest level in 18 years are also at play. Cotality head of research Gerard Burg said it is not entirely clear whether the reforms or rate changes are responsible.
Property data app Homer analysed 2,164 sales in the past month. Homes where the reserve matched the price guide had a 59% sale rate, compared with 50.4% for homes that revealed a higher reserve.
Homer chief executive Henry Pedersen said the reforms had not ended underquoting but had “shifted and exposed it”.
What was lost in New South Wales
The scrapped NSW package proposed higher fines for underquoting and a price guide on all advertisements. Minns cited one element in particular: a proposed ban on agents cutting the advertised price below their private estimate or a previous rejected offer, which he said could leave sellers who overvalued their property unable to meet the market.
Sydney buyers’ agent Kimberley Ackerman said that element was poorly designed but that the rest of the reform could have been salvaged.













