French Protesters Question Whether Police Tear Gas Is Disrupting Menstrual Health, as Scientists Await Evidence

tear gas reproductive health: Tear gas and reproductive health: French activists and lawmakers want police to suspend tear gas use after women reported painful cramps, unexpected bleeding and disrupted menstrual cycles. Scientists have not confirmed a medical link, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez has rejected the calls.

Tear gas and reproductive health, Digimart Global (France): French activists and lawmakers are calling on authorities to suspend the use of tear gas to disperse crowds after recent street protests. They argue the chemical may be causing menstrual changes and other reproductive health problems, although scientists have not confirmed a medical connection.

The demands follow police use of tear gas during student protests and demonstrations over the cost of living, some of which were marred by violence. Some women reported painful cramps, unexpected bleeding and disrupted menstrual cycles after exposure, and an advocacy group says it has collected more than 10,000 complaints.

Opposition lawmakers are seeking a ban and independent research into possible health effects.

What Is in French Tear Gas

Tear gas grenades used by French police contain CS, a chemical irritant that affects the eyes, skin and respiratory tract. CS is a crystalline powder dispersed into the air as fine particles.

Its effects depend on how much is used and how long people are exposed, and those affected during the protests included peaceful demonstrators, children, pregnant women, older people and residents near protest routes.

Women Describe Pain and Bleeding

Mélina Galland, 24, a freelance photographer, said she felt intense belly pain after tear gas grenades were fired during Oct. 17 protests in Paris that were marred by rioting and looting. Chloé Baroux, 25, also a photographer, said she first noticed pain and irregular periods after covering protests against a security bill in 2020 and 2021, and that her cycles became irregular again over the past two months.

Eva-Luna Tholance, a former journalist, founded the advocacy group “Lacrymos de sang” (“Tears of blood”) during the protests to raise awareness of possible effects on menstrual cycles and pregnancies. The group asked people to complete a questionnaire about their exposure and symptoms.

Its accounts do not establish how common the symptoms are, and they have not been reviewed by independent doctors.

What Research Shows So Far

An Associated Press investigation during the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests in the United States found limited study and oversight of tear gas. A recent study of symptoms reported after those protests found a “potential relationship” between exposure and “adverse reproductive health outcomes”, but it did not prove cause and effect, partly because it relied on self-reported information.

Its lead author, Asha Hassan of the University of Minnesota Medical School, said the study calls for more research urgently.

Government Position

The French Interior Ministry says no published scientific studies show that CS causes menstrual changes or miscarriages. It said other effects of tear gas generally resolve within hours, though it acknowledged that longer-lasting skin and eye symptoms “cannot be ruled out”.

The ministry said it conducted several studies in 2021 and 2022 on individual exposure, particularly among law enforcement personnel, but did not respond to an AP request for copies. Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez has rejected the calls, saying tear gas is essential to crowd control as an alternative to more dangerous weapons.

Alsetex and Nobel Sport, two suppliers of tear gas grenades to French law enforcement, did not respond to requests for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports

Explore Digimart Global