NSW home birth twin inquest, Digimart Global (Lismore, New South Wales): A New South Wales coroner’s court in Lismore heard on Thursday that a mother whose twin baby died was determined to give birth at home despite advice from experts, including her own midwife. The mother, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was pregnant with twins and did not want a hospital birth after hearing about others’ traumatic experiences.
The inquest is examining the deaths of four babies, Baby R, Baby D, Baby DH and Baby B, who were born in free births or home births in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024. The first three died after free births, where no medical professionals were present. Baby B died of a bacterial infection, while the other twin became sick but survived.
According to evidence presented to the court, the local medical community in the Hunter Valley warned the mother that a home birth was risky and prepared in case of emergency. Four midwives were part of the birthing plan for Baby B, and the main midwife continued to support the woman.
The midwife told the court the alternative was that the mother would give birth at home with no support whatsoever.
Expert evidence, including from Prof Hannah Dahlen, found the midwives’ treatment was reasonable and appropriate. Experts still considered a home birth unsuitable in the circumstances, citing the twin pregnancy, a pregnancy continuing beyond 41 weeks, the lack of specialist review, the family’s distance from hospital, and the possible need for urgent operative birth and simultaneous resuscitation of two babies.
The mother declined multiple checks and did not consent to hospital antenatal care or an obstetrician consultation, though scans were performed at 12 and 22 weeks. Her midwife recommended monthly ultrasounds and induction at 36 to 37 weeks, which the mother also declined.
The midwife said she warned of the risks at every visit.
The court heard that after ambulance officers and later police carried out a welfare check at the home, the mother became angry and more determined to avoid the health system. The first twin was born successfully and initially appeared to be fine, but in the early hours of the following morning Baby B was found not breathing.
Hospital staff worked for 45 minutes to save her, but she died.
The midwife told the court she surrendered her registration after the death. She said she was not told when Baby B died and only learned of the surviving twin’s situation through a call from the hospital.
The inquest is ongoing.













