Young men are struggling, but not all men are struggling equally, researchers say ahead of International Men’s Day

Young men disadvantage by social class, race and migrant background, Digimart Global: Debate about a supposed crisis facing young men often focuses on social media, gambling and the online “manosphere”, but an article published by The Conversation argues that some of the most consequential changes are happening in schools and workplaces. Men, on average, still have advantages in the labour market, yet social class, race and migrant background can make an enormous difference to their educational and employment prospects.

The authors say the debate is often framed as a culture war between men’s concerns and women’s progress, citing the persistent gender pay gap and the over-representation of men in the most senior jobs on one side, and young men who drop out of school and end up unemployed on the other. Ahead of International Men’s Day on 19 November, they call for a shift from asking whether men are “falling behind” to asking which men are struggling and why.

According to the article, research on workplace inequality has paid surprisingly little attention to men from disadvantaged backgrounds. The authors report that a Google Scholar search found 1,330 studies with “women” in the title compared with 234 mentioning “men”, a gap that was even wider in research on career advancement.

The article notes that the focus on women reflects real and continuing barriers, but that treating men as one group can obscure the experiences of those who are struggling.

The article says inequality often begins before people enter the workplace, with boys from low-income families and racialised or stigmatised migrant backgrounds tending to fall behind at school. It cites research suggesting students are more likely to finish school when teachers expect more of them, and says that lower expectations for disadvantaged boys can become a self-fulfilling cycle.

It also quotes social scientist Richard Reeves as saying young men in the United States are almost 50 per cent more likely than young women to drop out of high school.

The article describes a similar gap in Canada, where the 2021 census shows about one-quarter of Canadian-born men aged 25 to 34 held a bachelor’s degree or higher, compared with almost 40 per cent of Canadian-born women in the same age group. It says the labour market that once offered well-paid manual work to less-educated men has changed, noting that in 1970 high school dropouts held 43 per cent of American manufacturing jobs, while by 2016 fewer than 10 per cent of those jobs were held by workers who had not finished high school.

The authors argue that employment is growing in health care, education, administration and literacy occupations, and that an ageing population is increasing demand for care workers. They also say men remain substantially under-represented in much of this work, with about 91 per cent of regulated nurses in Canada being women and only about 25 per cent of elementary and high school teachers being men.

Some working-class men, the article suggests, have not been prepared for or encouraged towards these occupations, and some avoid them because caring and service work conflicts with their idea of a man’s job.

The article says attention to men’s disadvantage is often met with resistance, including a concern that supporting disadvantaged men could come at the expense of women’s gains. The authors argue that improving opportunities for disadvantaged men does not require reversing progress for women.

They cite French economists who have argued that revaluing female-dominated occupations could advance pay equity for women while drawing more men into this work, and a French study finding that male midwives helped the profession’s push for better recognition.

The article concludes that schools could pay closer attention to expectations for at-risk boys, that governments and employers could strengthen vocational pathways into occupations with labour shortages, and that seeing more men working as teachers, nurses and care workers could help boys consider these careers. It presents the analysis as a call for a more nuanced conversation on men being left behind, noting that men on average remain advantaged in many areas while not all men share those advantages.

Lachlan Prescott

Lachlan Prescott covers Australian breaking news, national affairs, government policies, and major developments across the country. His editorial focus is on delivering clear, factual, and balanced news coverage for Australian readers.
Copy Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports

Explore Digimart Global