Florida mechanic guilty murder case, Digimart Global (Florida): A Florida mechanic has been found guilty of stabbing to death a British music teacher whom he persuaded to travel to the United States, according to a report published by The Guardian.
Dwain Hall, an auto repair worker and tow truck driver, had contacted 32-year-old Sonia Exelby, from Portsmouth, England, on a fetish website before luring her to the US. Hall had pleaded not guilty to kidnapping and first-degree murder charges.
At the trial, jurors heard from several witnesses, most of them law enforcement officials, who described Hall’s emails, phone records, social media accounts and other records used to trace his movements after Exelby left the UK to meet him. Prosecutors said she suffered from mental illness, and investigators said she had travelled to Florida after posting online about wanting someone to end her life.
Investigation and evidence
Exelby’s disappearance from her home sparked an international investigation. According to the arrest affidavit, reported by the Ocala Starbanner, she had previously expressed suicidal thoughts, and investigators alleged that Hall knew about her struggles and used that vulnerability to bring her to Florida.
Authorities said Exelby boarded a flight to the US in October 2025, and that Hall picked her up from Gainesville airport in central Florida.
Hall then drove her to an Airbnb rental, where investigators said they found evidence connecting him to her disappearance and death, including transactions on her bank cards and a video of Exelby on Hall’s cellphone.
Defence and prosecution arguments
According to the Times, Hall’s attorney, Junior Barrett, argued in closing that Exelby took her own life and that the case should not be decided on Hall’s lifestyle. Prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt told jurors to use their common sense, saying Hall targeted Exelby for her mental illness and killed her for his sadistic pleasure.
Berndt described Exelby as kind and deeply loved, and said she had suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She said Hall took advantage of a severely depressed woman who was incapable of making rational decisions.
Family response
After the verdict was read, Exelby’s brother, Barry Wilton, said the past year had been one of the hardest of the family’s lives. Addressing Hall directly, he said Hall had pretended to care for Sonia and had used her to fulfil his fantasies, adding that he had the chance to save her but instead took her from them.













