Campaigners Back Scrutiny of Consent Laws After Joanne Young Drugging and Rape Case

third-party consent laws: Campaigners have welcomed calls for scrutiny of consent laws from Joanne Young, a survivor of drug-facilitated rape, after four men were convicted of sexual offences against her at Winchester Crown Court. Barristers and campaigners say the law does not allow consent to be given on someone else's behalf, and call for public debate and better education.

third-party consent laws, Digimart Global (Winchester, England): Campaigners have welcomed a call for scrutiny of consent laws by Joanne Young, a survivor of drug-facilitated rape, although they say action must also address wider issues around sexual assault. Young warned of “serious questions about how the law deals with consent” after her former husband, Philip Young, was found to have drugged her and arranged for other men to abuse her.

Philip Young, 50, a former Conservative councillor, advertised Joanne Young on dating and swinging websites, presenting it as a “kink” for both of them, Winchester Crown Court heard. He had been sedating her, leaving her in an “inanimate state” in which the men who answered the adverts could do anything to her, jurors were told.

He pleaded guilty earlier in the year to dozens of charges of abuse against his former wife, who has waived her right to anonymity.

On Thursday, four men were convicted of sexual offences against Joanne Young, who is 49. The trial heard that the men, who were strangers to each other, did not seek her consent before engaging in sexual activity with her. The defendants claimed they had been duped by Philip Young and believed she was consenting.

Joanne Young said: “No one should be able to give [consent] on your behalf.” Her daughter, Alex Young, called for a change in the law to make clear that third-party consent cannot be used as an argument in a court of law.

No law recognises third-party consent as a defence

Barristers and campaigners said there is no law stating that third-party consent is a valid defence. Kate Parker, a criminal barrister and founder of the Schools Consent Project, said the Sexual Offences Act 2003 does not allow someone to rely on what a third party told them.

She said defence counsel in cases like this were instead relying on the defence that the defendant genuinely and reasonably believed the victim was consenting.

Harriet Wistrich, a solicitor and director of the Centre for Women’s Justice, said the jury in the Young case had ultimately rejected the defence. She said it should be obvious in law that one person cannot consent on another’s behalf, but that the position could be made explicit, and urged defence barristers not to rely on myths and stereotypes.

Calls for education and possible legal change

Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, said the law on consent should be scrutinised, but that the existing law is already clear and is often misinterpreted and misapplied. The Sexual Offences Act 2003 states that a person consents “if he agrees by choice, and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.” Professor Miranda Horvath, director of the Institute for Social Justice and Crime at the University of Suffolk, said incorrect beliefs about consent should be robustly challenged through clear education.

The Labour MP Jess Phillips said the government should examine whether the law could be tightened to state more firmly that consent cannot come from a third party. A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said the law is clear that no one can consent on someone else’s behalf, and that the government keeps the criminal law under review and will always look at what more can be done to protect victims.

Freya Sullivan

Freya Sullivan covers British politics, parliamentary affairs, government policies, and economic developments. Her reporting explores major decisions, business trends, and public policy issues shaping the United Kingdom's political and economic landscape.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports

Explore Digimart Global