Why Fear-Based Leadership Is Failing Workplaces and Politics, Writes TimesLIVE Columnist

strongman leadership at work: a TimesLIVE opinion piece argues that fear-driven leadership, in workplaces and politics alike, erodes trust and engagement, citing Gallup data showing only 18% of South African employees engaged at work and the turnaround at SARS as an example.

Strongman leadership at work, Digimart Global: A TimesLIVE opinion piece published on 21 November 2026 argues that the appeal of strongman leadership, in politics and in the workplace, may be fuelling disengagement and division rather than solving them. The article draws on Gallup’s 2026 State of the Global Workplace report, which found that only 18% of South African employees are engaged at work and that 26% are thriving in their lives, while 36% experience significant daily stress.

The author links these figures to a wider human tendency. Citing a 2025 study across 25 countries by Laustsen, Sheng, Ahmad and colleagues, the piece suggests that during periods of intergroup conflict, people may instinctively prefer tough, dominant leaders.

The author argues that this instinct, though once possibly useful for group survival, may still shape leadership preferences in today’s uncertain environment.

The article argues that the same dynamic can appear inside organisations. When companies face pressure, the instinct to tighten control can produce short-term compliance and higher output, but may also make staff reluctant to speak openly, admit mistakes or take risks.

In the author’s view, this shift from engagement to mere compliance can ultimately undermine trust and performance. The piece is careful to note that workplace disengagement has many causes, including economic pressure, job insecurity and poor management, and that a direct link to politics would oversimplify the picture.

As a case study, the author points to the South African Revenue Service (SARS). According to the article, under commissioner Tom Moyane from 2014 to 2018, the Nugent Commission described a culture of fear, suspicion and distrust, and revenue collections repeatedly fell short.

After Moyane’s dismissal in 2018, Edward Kieswetter was appointed commissioner in 2019 and focused on rebuilding trust and developing staff. The article reports that between 2019 and 2025, SARS’s own engagement index rose from 61% to 71%, public trust rose from 48% to 75%, and revenue collections exceeded R2-trillion in the 2025/26 financial year for the first time.

The author also comments on recent US midterm elections, in which Democrats won sweeping victories in the House of Representatives and Senate. The article notes that these results were influenced by many factors, including rising costs, the war in Iran and dissatisfaction with Republican performance, and says it would be premature to declare the end of strongman politics in the United States.

The piece concludes that leaders who build trust, accountability and co-operation, rather than fear, may better serve both organisations and society.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports

Explore Digimart Global