Supported exempt accommodation Birmingham, Digimart Global (Birmingham, England): Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, who is also MP for Birmingham Ladywood, has said she “smells a rat” over housing provision for vulnerable people in her constituency, citing warnings about spiralling costs and the risk of exploitation. Her comments, reported by the Birmingham Mail and republished by the Guardian, come as a push for an independent investigation into the supported exempt accommodation (SEA) sector in Birmingham gathers pace.
The SEA system is designed to support people with additional needs, including those with addiction, women fleeing domestic abuse and former prisoners. Providers offer housing alongside care, support and supervision.
Politicians, charities and residents have, however, raised concerns about rogue providers who fail to deliver the required support, as well as risks of exploitation and antisocial behaviour.
Council review findings
An internal examination by Birmingham city council this week found that more than £615m in SEA housing benefit had been paid over 15 months without “timely evidence” that relevant support had been given to residents. According to the review, the council paid £404.4m in SEA housing benefit in the year commencing April 2024, and a further £211.8m in the four months from April 2026.
The review, commissioned by the council’s cross-party audit committee, concluded that the local authority’s approach to the sector was not fully effective. It found 12,700 live cases were awaiting a review to confirm that care, support and supervision were being provided after a tenancy began.
In some cases, SEA housing benefit claims had been active for more than a decade, and some for more than 20 years, without being subject to eligibility checks.
Political and official responses
Mahmood told the Birmingham Mail that she sees the impact of SEA across her constituency and that abuse in the sector is contributing to many of the problems in local communities. She said Birmingham was an “outlier” compared with the rest of the country and that she had discussed the enhanced housing benefits that fund the sector with Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden.
Birmingham has more than 34,000 people living in SEA across approximately 12,200 properties, compared with 22,000 SEA residents in London, a city with a population roughly seven times larger.
Marcus Bernasconi, a Labour councillor, backed calls for an independent investigation and said the council had “totally lost control” of supported accommodation. A Birmingham city council spokesperson said the review showed the council’s process for assessing housing benefit claims was robust, but argued that there is no adequate regulation for the council to effectively oversee the sector in the city.
A government spokesperson said ministers were monitoring supported housing in Birmingham and were considering next steps, adding that councils are being given stronger powers to fine non-compliant landlords. Legislation passed in 2023 to strengthen regulation, including a new licensing scheme, remains under consultation.













