Generational fairness in Canada public spending, Digi Mart USA News (Canada): In a commentary published in The Globe and Mail, contributing columnist Claude Lavoie, a former director-general of economic studies and policy analysis at the Department of Finance, argues that Canada’s public finances tilt too far toward older generations. He writes that the latest federal budget made progress in many areas but did little to ease the burden on future generations.
Lavoie points to recent protests by young people across Europe over class inequality and the sense that their generation carries more than its share. He says similar tensions are visible in Canada, citing student walkouts in Ontario this month over provincial cuts to tuition assistance and the work of think tanks such as Generation Squeeze.
According to Lavoie, Canada’s fiscal position has deteriorated since the 1990s pension and public finance reforms, and the budget does not expect it to improve. He also cites C.D.
Howe Institute projections that the ratio of seniors to working-age people will rise to close to 50 per cent in 2070 from about 30 per cent today at the current immigration rate, and he argues that raising immigration is not a sustainable solution.
Rather than across-the-board cuts to health care, Old Age Security or the Guaranteed Income Supplement, Lavoie proposes targeting higher-income seniors. He suggests raising the OAS clawback rate above a certain income threshold, reviewing the pension and age tax credits, and allowing TFSA withdrawals to count toward OAS clawback calculations.
Lavoie also outlines broader options, including a more generous Canada Pension Plan, tax changes that shift more of the burden toward consumption, a progressive inheritance tax and a capital gains tax on land or house value above a threshold. He further suggests that widows receive extra support and that some income-tested user fees on non-preventive health care could be considered.
These are proposals from the column, not announced government policy.












